Your interview is going great. You’re clicking with the interviewer, the position sounds like the perfect fit. But then comes the question you’ve been dreading: “So, what are your salary expectations?”
The panic starts setting in… If you say too high of a number you might screen yourself out of the role. But if you say too low of a number then you could be stuck with it for years.
In the end, you might find yourself mumbling something about being “flexible” and then just hoping for the best.
At TGHR, our recruiters ask this question every single day, so here’s the honest version from the other side of the call: what we’re actually listening for, how to land on your number, and exactly what to say.
Why interviewers + recruiters ask
It’s not a trap! As someone who has this conversation on a daily basis, my one and only goal is to see if you and the role are even in the same ballpark. If the job budget maxes out at $55,000 and you need $70,000, it’s kinder to both of us to know that on our first call instead of after three rounds of interviews.
I’m not trying to get you an offer for as little money as possible. At a staffing firm like ours, we only do well when the placement works, and a person who feels underpaid doesn’t stay long. Your number helps me know which roles to put you up for and how hard to push when we go to bat for you with the employer.
That said, not every recruiter or hiring manager plays it the same way. So it pays to go in prepared either way.
Know your number before you interview
The worst time to figure out what you’re willing to accept as a salary is in the middle of a call or interview. You’ve got to do your homework first!
Start with what similar roles pay at this employer or similar companies. Look up job posts for the same title in the Indy area that list a range, check the free wage data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, and look at salary guides from local staffing firms (including ours, if you’d like a starting point).
National averages can be way off from central Indiana, so local numbers matter more.
Then land on three numbers for yourself:
- Your walk-away number is the lowest pay that actually works for your bills and your life.
- Your target number is what the market supports for your experience.
- Your stretch number is the top of what’s realistic if everything lines up.
You’ll only say one of these out loud, but knowing all three keeps you from caving when you feel put on the spot.
One important thing I always tell my candidates: the first number you say is the one you’ll negotiate down from, never up. So don’t open with your ‘I could make it work’ number. Open with the number you’d be genuinely excited to hear, and let us figure out if we can get there together.
But also, I encourage job seekers to think beyond the paycheck. A role with great health insurance, a hybrid schedule, or a bonus might be worth more than one with a slightly higher base. Know which of those things you’d trade for, and which you won’t.

What to say (word for word)
Of course, there’s no one perfect answer, because it depends on what you already know about the role. You can use these guidelines though for the situations we see come up the most.
When the job post lists a range that works for you…
Keep it simple and confirm if you’re aligned. If your experience puts you toward the top end, say so now.
“The range in the posting works for me. With my five years in accounts payable, I’d expect to land toward the upper end of it.”
When you know your number…
Give a range, and set the bottom of it at your target (not your walk-away). Whatever you say first tends to become the anchor.
“Based on what I’m seeing for similar roles in Indianapolis and my experience, I’m looking for something in the $58,000 to $64,000 range.”
When you’d rather hear their range first…
It’s completely fair to ask and most good recruiters will tell you.
“I’m flexible depending on the full picture. Can you share the budgeted range for the role? That’ll help me tell you if we’re in the same ballpark.”
When they push for a single number…
Don’t fight it more than once. Give your target and leave space to discuss .
“If I had to pick one number, I’d say $62,000, but I’m open to talking through the whole package, including benefits and schedule.”
When you’re currently underpaid
Your current paycheck doesn’t have to set the bar for your next one. Talk about the market, not your history.
“I know I’m below market right now, which is part of why I’m looking. For this role, I’m targeting $55,000 to $60,000.”
Related Post: How to Job Search While You’re Still Employed
When you’re changing careers or going for an entry-level role…
Lead with flexibility, but still have a number. Just saying “Whatever you think is fair…” can absolutely leave money on the table.
“Since I’m moving into HR from customer service, I’m open on pay. I’m hoping for something around $45,000, and I’d love to hear what’s typical for this role.”
Related Post: How to Get into HR with No HR Experience
Swap in your own numbers, of course. (These are just there to offer you guidelines for a good answer.)
What not to say
- “I don’t know, whatever’s fair.” It sounds easygoing, but it gives the whole decision to the other side. Even a rough range is better than no range.
- A range that’s way too wide. “$40,000 to $80,000” tells us nothing, and most people will hear only the bottom number.
- Your personal budget. Rent, student loans, and daycare costs are real, but pay is based on the role and the market. Don’t share personal details that aren’t necessary.
- A number you’d be upset to get. If you’d be disappointed by the low end of your own range, raise the low end before you say it out loud.
- Anything that isn’t true. Padding your current salary can come back around to bite you in the you-know-where, especially in a city where people know each other. You never have to share more than you want to, but don’t just make things up.
“What do you make now?” is a different question
Salary expectations are about what you want to get paid in your next role. Salary history is about what you’ve been paid before. They often get asked back to back, but you can treat them differently.
Just so you know, in some states, employers aren’t allowed to ask about your past pay, but Indiana isn’t one of them. Here, private employers can legally ask about your salary history and use it to make hiring decisions. You should also know they aren’t required to post a pay range either (Brightmine), even though we highly recommend doing so. Be aware if you’re based in Indianapolis, this question is likely to come up.
You’re still allowed to steer the conversation back to the new role in consideration. I’d recommend saying something like:
“I’d rather focus on what’s right for this role. Based on my research and experience, I’m looking for $58,000 to $64,000.”
If you’d like to share your current pay, you can do so cautiously. However, just make sure to mention your target salary so your current pay doesn’t become the ceiling.
Let us do the awkward part
When you work with a recruiter at That’s Good HR, the pay conversation gets a lot easier. Tell us your real number once, and we’ll only put you up for roles that fit that. Then we handle the back-and-forth with the employer for you, so you don’t have to negotiate against yourself.
Browse our current openings in HR, admin, and accounting & finance, or reach out and tell us what you’re looking for next.